Justice Department appeals mask ruling after CDC says mandate “remains necessary for the public health” – What We Know!

The Justice Division has filed an attraction that seeks to reverse a decide’s current ruling that ended the nation’s masks mandate on public transit. The Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention had requested the division to attraction the choice, issuing a press release Wednesday that stated the mandate “stays needed for the general public well being.”

“CDC continues to suggest that folks put on masks in all indoor public transportation settings,” the CDC’s assertion continued. “CDC’s primary precedence is defending the general public well being of our nation. As we now have stated earlier than, carrying masks is most useful in crowded or poorly ventilated places, such because the transportation hall.”

The Justice Division stated Tuesday it will attraction U.S. District Choose Kathryn Kimball Mizelle’s determination provided that the CDC stated the mandate was nonetheless needed. The division stated Tuesday that it disagreed with the district courtroom’s determination, and upon submitting the attraction, Justice Division spokesman Anthony Coley issued a press release Wednesday saying, “In mild of as we speak’s evaluation by the CDC that an order requiring masking within the transportation hall stays needed to guard the general public well being, the Division has filed a discover of attraction in Well being Freedom Protection Fund, Inc., et al., v. Biden, et al.

On Monday, Mizelle voided the CDC’s requirement overlaying airplanes and different public transit, ruling that the mandate exceeded the authority of U.S. well being officers. Within the aftermath, the Transportation Safety Administration stated it will now not implement the mandate.

The decide’s determination got here days after the CDC had prolonged the masks mandate, which had been set to run out Monday, by two weeks to offer researchers extra time to review the Omicron subvariant BA.2.   

Nevertheless, the response to the ruling has been different. Some cities, together with New York Metropolis and Philadelphia, nonetheless require masks to be worn in airports and on public transportation, whereas others, comparable to Houston and Atlanta, don’t. Even airways now have differing guidelines for masking, though most now say masks are non-compulsory for passengers. Amtrak has additionally stated masks are now not required on trains or in stations.

Requested Tuesday if individuals ought to nonetheless put on masks on planes, President Biden replied: “That’s as much as them,” in response to The Related Press.

Dr. Céline Gounder, an infectious illness knowledgeable and editor-at-large for Kaiser Well being Information, advised “CBS Mornings” that the CDC’s extension was the “applicable” and “cautious” method.

“We all know that this virus mutates. Actually, it’s mutating very quickly,” she stated. “We’ll see extra variants, and we are going to see different pandemics after COVID. So I do suppose the concept of stripping ourselves of a necessary device and toolbox is a very dangerous thought.”

Victoria Albert and Robert Legare contributed reporting.