The Murder of Mindy Morgenstern – dead and Obituary – What We Know!

The Murder of Mindy Morgenstern - dead and Obituary

In that case, I watched an episode of Heartland Homicide. That is Season 3, Episode 1, titled “The Farmer’s Daughter.”

A younger lady was discovered useless in her house.


Mindy Morgenstern was 22 when he died as a scholar at Valley Metropolis State College.

Her dad and mom, Eunice and Larry, adopted her and her sister from Bogota, Colombia. They grew up in New Salem, a small city about 165 miles from Valley Metropolis. Mindy is described as a tomboy who loves basketball, rides horses and helps out on the farm. She was nervous about beginning school, however her mom reminded her to breathe and she or he may do it.


On September 13, 2006, Mindy’s mates Toni Baumann and Danielle Holmstrom known as her to ask if they might be part of her for a drink. Mindy didn’t reply, in order that they determined to go to her house.

After they arrived, Tony went upstairs to the house and Danielle was ready within the automotive. Tony then ran again to inform Danielle that Mindy was useless and had one thing on his neck.

The 2 walked into the darkish house. Mindy was discovered mendacity on the bottom. There was additionally a belt round her neck that strangled her. Her throat was additionally severed and she or he was practically decapitated. A bottle of pine sol spilled throughout her face, neck and chest.

Whereas Tony and Danielle have been within the house, a neighbor ran in to test Mindy’s pulse. Danielle described it as unusual and she or he had by no means seen the person earlier than. Associates then known as 911.


Valley Metropolis and North Dakota BCI police have been concerned in Mindy’s case.

Police described the scene as scary. Two knives have been discovered close by, the hilts have been certainly damaged. Mindy fights again, discovering the killer’s DNA below her fingernails. Pores and skin cells have been collected and despatched to a criminal offense lab.

There have been no indicators of break-in or theft. Mindy’s mates mentioned they didn’t know anybody wished Mindy useless.


The primary individual to be requested was Mindy’s neighbor. They requested him what he was doing when he murdered her, which the coroner decided between 12.23pm and 12.47pm.

A neighbour mentioned he heard “uncommon noise” whereas watching TV. He mentioned he bumped into the house and Mindy gave the impression to be strangled.

Police carried out a background test on him, and he served time in jail. In addition they requested in regards to the marks on his palms. He mentioned he obtained it from work. Police took his DNA and launched him briefly.

Suspicious individual

Within the days following Mindy’s dying, folks gathered across the house complicated. A person catches the eye of Mindy’s mates, particularly her pal Lacey.

Lacey instructed Valley Metropolis Sheriff Dave Swenson in regards to the man. Lacey instructed Sgt. Swenson that the person was carrying a laundry basket and appeared unaware that mates and acquaintances have been mourning the lack of a pal.

The person has been recognized as Morris “Moe” Gibbs. He has served time in jail however presently serves as a corrections officer. He additionally served as an evening watchman on the college.

Mo was requested about his time within the navy. Moe mentioned he was dishonorably fired for the assault. His DNA was additionally extracted and he was launched.


Mindy and her ex-boyfriend dated for about 2-3 years however broke up a couple of months earlier than her dying. In keeping with him, her character was very frivolous. He mentioned that they had been in contact for some time, however she had been in contact together with his father.

He mentioned he was upset that they have been nonetheless in contact and it was damaging their relationship. His father, who turned out to be one of many final to name Mindy, was additionally introduced in.

Each the boyfriend’s and father’s DNA have been extracted and it was finally discovered that they didn’t match. You may have been expelled from faculty.

Mindy’s police report

A number of weeks earlier than her dying, Mindy went to the police station to report that she was being adopted. She was horrified and instructed her mom and mates.

Mindy works as a waitress at Roby’s, a well-liked native restaurant. Mindy is described as a well-liked waitress with a person dwelling within the motorhome throughout the road.

The person, described as a homeless and loner, was taken for questioning. He instructed police he didn’t know Mindy and had by no means been to the restaurant.

The person had wounds on his arm and mentioned he was doing a little upkeep. He was finally fired when his DNA didn’t match.

DNA outcomes

On September 18, 5 days after Mindy’s dying, the DNA outcomes got here again. DNA collected from Mindy’s fingernails was returned to Moe Gibbs as a match.

Moe was requested to return to the station, this time for a polygraph take a look at. The examiner instructed Moe that he had conflicting solutions and requested how his DNA was discovered below Mindy’s fingernails. Moe mentioned he didn’t know, however had by no means been to her house.